Interview: Garth Risk Hallberg
From the Vault: an interview first published at Pages to Pixels in July 2011.
From the Vault. First published at Pages to Pixels on July 14, 2011.


Though I’d heard of his well-received book, A Field Guide to the North American Family, it wasn’t until I read his article on The Millions, “Kindle-Proof Your Book in Seven Easy Steps!” that I knew an interview—pending his confirmation—was inevitable.
Thankfully, Mr. Hallberg accepted, and below there’s posted our interesting exploration of electronic media, literature-qua-art, and design.
Garth numbers among a shrinking group of writers who still consider “the book” to be a vessel of art—rather than a vehicle for profit margins—which exists, ideally, as a honed combination of formally aware content and design-prone presentation.
A Field Guide to the North American Family, stands as such a work; graphics and textual content are weighed evenly—both well-formed—, resulting in an evocative, challenging—and certainly kindle-proof—artwork.
Besides authoring A Field Guide, Garth Risk Hallberg works as a staff writer for The Millions, and he’s published in Slate, The Los Angeles Times: Jacket Copy, among others. He currently teaches at Fordham University.
The Interview
PAGES TO PIXELS
Your acclaimed novella, The Field Guide to the North American Family, partners strong visual elements with written content. Were you at all nervous of the work being dismissed as “gimmicky” by the stodgy literary gatekeepers?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
First, thanks for approaching me to talk, and second, apologies for what’s going to be a long answer to your first question. And also, it looks like, your second and your fourth.
I feel myself hesitating a little around the term “stodgy” (and of course, the term “acclaimed”). That is, I’m not sure that literary gatekeepers are particularly one adjective or another, or even, circa 2011 particularly powerful. “Intermediaries” might be a better word than “gatekeepers,” as it implies no special glory on the other side of the gate. Though literature continues notionally to occupy a position of prestige in American culture, publishing folk are the Keebler elves of the entertainment industry, and I imagine most of them are just concerned to hang on to their jobs. (I’m assuming ”gatekeepers” doesn’t encompass critics, who are – and I’m speaking as a sometime member of that tribe – even more marginal figures, and perhaps more admirable for that.)
In order to stay employed, agents editors and publishers have to be attentive to the exigencies of the marketplace, which dictate a certain ratio of yoga books to, say, books of Uruguayan poetry. But that’s ideally neither here nor there for the writer. Even more ideally, maybe the sense of an ossifying economy frees the writer to ignore, out of a kind of despair, what’s selling and who’s buying and to follow instead his or her inclinations, however idiosyncratic, the way writers used to ignore the quite differently ossified and despair-inducing literary marketplace of the old Eastern Bloc. Unless, that is, the writer wants fame or money, in which case – as was also true in the Eastern Bloc – he or she is probably S.O.L. I’ve written, tongue in cheek, about being crushed that I’m not a millionaire, but really, that’s not true. The part about being crushed, I mean. I am in fact still not a millionaire.
But to get back around to your question, readers, not “literary gatekeepers,” is the constituency for whom I worried the visual elements might seem gimmicky. But the photographs were, for good or for ill, part of the conception. Unusually for me, I should say.
I want to just add that my ideal reader is a patient one, too, as is my ideal human being. One of my favorite contemporary novels is Norman Rush’s Mortals. It takes about 250 pages for you to figure out that you can trust the writer (unless you’ve already read Mating). I admire the hell out of Rush for staying true to his conception of the novel.
It would be a much less powerful book if he had dispatched our concerns on page 1. His editor, wanting to find him the widest readership possible, probably disagreed.
PAGES TO PIXELS
For Slate, you wrote an amusing piece exposing “Grady Harp,” a top Amazon reviewer who gave The Field Guide good marks, as a fraud. The ‘Grady Harp Phenomenon’ seems indicative of larger problems introduced by the Internet to literary art. Imprecise ranking, skewed reviews, a lack of transparency; does the Internet hurt more than it helps?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
I’d hope to think of the Internet, in the best of all possible worlds, as a reasonable person would: as neither here nor there vis-a-vis literature. Like the Kitchen-Aid Mixer or something. To the extent that we don’t live in that world, though, and also to the extent that I’m not a reasonable person, I guess I consider the Internet’s effect on literature to be more baleful than not – though not quite in the way the Grady Harp story suggests. (Ah! That’s what you meant by ”acclaimed!”) Qualitative ranking has always been imprecise, reviews generally skewed.
On the whole, from my point of view, the Internet problem resembles more closely the television problem David Foster Wallace sketched in his essay “E. Unibus Pluram.” That is, in exaggerating the evils of TV, he might have come close to accurately describing the problems its successor poses for writers. At any rate, I don’t think “A Chatroom of One’s Own” has quite the same ring.
The web is just a huge distraction; it seems to me to train us away from the kind of patience and idiosyncrasy I was praising above. Our readers, too. Some people more tough-minded than I am – Keith Gessen, for one – would probably say that’s good; it weeds out those who don’t have what it takes. But the general drift away from the kind of space and depth and solitude––the “silence, cunning, and exile” the most credible writers tend to talk about in their Paris Review interviews––seems like a loss for everyone, not just writers.
Then again, writers need enemies to fight against. So maybe it’s a blessing after all. Plus the Internet makes it easier to keep up correspondence, so that’s something.
PAGES TO PIXELS
You’ve described yourself as “an extracurricular binge-reader of 1960s and ’70s ‘experimental’ literature.” Pages to Pixels is down with that. However, it seems that—either for financial or less pragmatic reasons—not many others are. Do you feel as if innovation, in our era of Walmart romance lit, has slowed a bit?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
I’m guessing experimental literature, broadly defined, has always been a niche product. And certainly, it hasn’t always been good, any more than “traditional” literature has. (Though all great literature innovates.) You can find plenty of innovation now, too –– of kinds obvious and not-so-obvious, good and not-so-good –– if you’re willing to look for it. If there’s a recent challenge to innovation, it would seem to me to be bound up less with economics than with cultural changes, assuming those are separable.
I sense an increasing hostility to anyone openly making a claim to value (e.g., writing a really long book, or claiming explicitly, as Jonathan Franzen does somewhere, ”Look – the work I’m doing is simply better than the work Dean Koontz is doing”). That hostility is often couched in democratic terms, invoking the term “elitist.” The more naked the attempt to “make it new,” the more you’re sort of asserting a claim for what you’re doing as art, rather than vulgar commerce.
And those kinds of claims seem to be more problematic for people now than they were in the days of such innovative works as Joseph Heller’s Something Happened or Grace Paley’s The Little Disturbances of Man. I think the word “pretentious” has become much overused as a synonym for “ambitious.” Same thing ”professorial” as a pejorative term for a politician. Same thing with the idea of “taking yourself too seriously.” Isn’t that what writers are, in some sense, supposed to do?
PAGES TO PIXELS
You wrote a post for The Millions entitled, “Kindle-Proof Your Book in Seven Easy Steps!” Among your recommendations: “Step 1: Use Color.” E-readers certainly lack artfulness; how is it that they’re selling so well?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
That piece, as I mentioned, was as much tongue-in-cheek as cri de coeur, but I was trying to point out that an eReader, treated as a book, surpasses the book in very few respects, and lags behind in many (including some important ones I didn’t mention). The main selling point of the device, as I understand it, is the ability to carry around hundreds of books, but with some exceptions – dissertation writers, e.g., or long-vacationers – this would seem to have little to do with the way most readers use their books.
I do think there are kinds of readers––those of mystery novels, romances, textbooks, or those of very of-the-moment books of journalism––who don’t feel a particular urge to hold onto or reread their books. Which seems perfectly reasonable to me; if I read a Seymour Hersh book, which I do whenever there is one, I might then donate it to the library. These readers may constitute the majority of book-buyers, and for them, the eBook probably is a cheaper way to buy books, and saves shelf space.
But I do believe that the codex book––more like the towel than the Walkman––is not a technology that was crying out for improvement or replacement. (Often, these are the technologies we improve upon at our own risk, with all kinds of unintended consequences.) And, to be cynical, I feel the same kind of push going on to move everyone over to eReaders that went on with the cell-phone ten years ago. You use the special case to justify the general case. Also: peer pressure.
Watch the Times in the run-up to the Christmas holidays; every third article will suddenly be about the Kindle, even if, when you dig deeper, a 30% year-over-year jump in the number of eReaders means a jump from 1% of the population to 1.3%. It seems unmistakable that a market is being made. (As Robert Oppenheimer noted, once something becomes technologically possible, we tend to do it without asking questions.) It’s when adoption is near universal that we tend to find out what the people making the market want. With the cell phone, it was to increase your monthly out-of-pocket from $30 to $130. With the eReader, I suspect that Amazon, Apple, &c. ultimately aim to cut out those intermediaries we were talking about above – to absorb their diminishing shares of the pie.
PAGES TO PIXELS
Standardization—if you want sales—seems to be the game; standardized devices, standardized stories, standardized plots. What might you recommend to a writer trying to break out a little?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
I’m not sure I know how to answer this one. You just have to sit down and try to write the thing that only you can write, and that you’d write if it was the only thing you ever got to. And you have to need, somehow, to do that. Which often requires going out and living––not in the Hemingway sense, but in the just everyday people sense––and getting your ass kicked by life and writing a bunch of stuff that’s not the right stuff first. Patience, I guess is what I’m recommending.
Patience and passion.
PAGES TO PIXELS
How do you feel about Donald Barthelme?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
I like Barthelme a lot. I teach “The School,” as well as a fifteenth-generation Xeroxed packet that originated on Barthelme’s typewriter on 13th Street called “The Perfect Sentence.” I like ”Critique de la Vie Quotidienne” a lot, and “Miss Mandible and Me,” and just a lot of what’s in 60 Stories. That said, he’s not a writer who changed my life…not yet, anyway. I wasn’t coming to him by way of Updike, but by way of Pynchon, so the explosive quality of the sentences didn’t have for me the force of revelation it might have otherwise.
And if I can level with you, I feel like Barthelme is one of those writers whose hand lies too heavy on the prose of writers under 40 today, particularly those in certain a three- or four-year run of McSweeney’s. I’m all for influence, but he’s one of those writers whose style(s) is/are so distinctive that when his voice is in your head it’s hard not to sound derivative. Like Faulkner that way. Maybe someone will come along and do with Barthelme what Cormac McCarthy did with Faulkner. If so, I look forward to it.
PAGES TO PIXELS
Writers: Unacknowledged legislators or normal, albeit curious, people?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
Neither? There’s definitely something abnormal about the compulsion to socialize with imaginary people for three to eight hours a day. And it would seem to limit one’s impact on the body politic.
PAGES TO PIXELS
N+1 and Slate recently published an article entitled “MFA vs. NYC,” discussing the artistic viability of America’s “two distinct literary cultures.” You received your MFA at NYU, which probably exposed you to each. Which might you suggest to a writer hoping to break into literary circles?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
Read Lost Illusions. Make your own circles. Listen to Lou Reed’s ”Work,” from Songs for Drella. “No matter what I did it never seemed enough / He said I was lazy; I said I was young. / He said, “How many songs did you write?” / I’d written zero / I lied and said, “Ten.” / ”You won’t be young forever; / You should have written fifteen. / It’s work.”
Good luck.
PAGES TO PIXELS
Who’ve you been reading recently ?
GARTH RISK HALLBERG
I have a 15-month-old son, who has changed me from a fast reader of single books at a time to a slow reader of many at once. As in I keep picking up new ones before finishing the old, and then when things get out of hand taking a month to polish things off. Which is usually spent binging on Philip Roth or Martin Amis instead. However, it gives me pleasure to look at the pile of books by my bed and see the weird party that seems to be going on there, with friends old and new.
Right now: Galsworthy’s The Forsyte Saga; Gregory Bateson’s Steps to an Ecology of Mind; Jeffrey Eugenides’ The Marriage Plot; Laszlo Krasznahorkai’s Animalinside; Edie Meidav’s Lola, California; Gertrude Stein’s The Making of Americans; Cesar Aira’s The Seamstress and the Wind ; Richard Rhodes’ Dark Sun; Joseph McElroy’s Plus; James’ The Varieties of Religious Experience; Nicola Barker’s Darkmans; Updike’s Odd Jobs; and Whitman’s 1855 Leaves of Grass.
I hope to knock off the first five in July, which is less work than it sounds (Animalinside is very short), and Odd Jobs is a kind of dip into and out of thing. Stein and Whitman are sort of always there, for when I need peace of mind. They’re at this party on the floor by my bed, but I didn’t have to introduce them; they know each other quite well already. Also: A shout-out to UVA’s Deborah Eisenberg, one of the five or so best living American writers, who has a new story in the New York Review of Books.