Journal Profile: Guernica
Reposted November 22, 2026 · Originally published August 17, 2011, at Pages to Pixels. Part 1 of a 2-part series.

In August 2011, Guernica had just reached a million unique readers in a single month and still had no one to pay its bills. I asked its co-founder, Joel Whitney, whether art and politics could share a page. He answered with the Cold War: The Paris Review, he said, had been launched with CIA money. Six years later he published a book about it.
Asked Twice · A 2-part series. Part 1 is our 2011 profile of Guernica, as it ran. Part 2 is Guernica: Where They Are Now: what happened to the magazine, and to the editor who answered for it.
5 lines from this profile that turned out to matter
- "The Paris Review, was launched … as a CIA front, or at least with CIA money." In 2017 Whitney published Finks: How the C.I.A. Tricked the World's Best Writers (OR Books).
- "Our search for a benefactor continues." His last answer. In 2014 Guernica announced its first full-time publisher and an investment in long-term growth (Guernica).
- "We're not afraid to spark arguments." In March 2024, an argument over one essay cost the magazine much of its masthead (JTA).
- "First to publish fiction by Rivka Galchen." Galchen is now a staff writer at The New Yorker (Columbia University).
- "Adam Day … came to us via our unsolicited pile." Day has since published Model of a City in Civil War (Sarabande, 2015) and Left-Handed Wolf (LSU, 2020) (Wikipedia).
The Profile
In 2011 I labeled Joel Whitney's answers "GUERNICA MAGAZINE" rather than with his name; the labels are kept as they ran.
PAGES TO PIXELS
The Internet has allowed hundreds of arts magazines and literary journals to flourish. How does yours differ, in either intention or success, from the others?
GUERNICA MAGAZINE
In some ways ours differs by taking little pieces of what we loved most. We're hybridized. We loved the long writer interviews that The Paris Review does, and wondered if you could have a series that honors the voice of polemicists and activists and political thinkers in the same way; we loved the cross-genre arts interviews that BOMB does and saw a possible model for interviews-as-conversations in that; we loved how Ploughshares and the Best-American series use guest editors to create micro-climates within their own aesthetics. And we stole.
But maybe the single biggest difference is that Guernica looked at politics as the arts' twin sibling in the family of culture. We want our ratio of arts coverage–our attention to aesthetics–to be higher than in current events or general interest magazines. And we wanted politics to be seen as part of that culture, which it undeniably is, and to be handled the way it is in opinion journals, in the sense of taking sides in the disputes. So there's that.
But we're really just looking for great writing and great ideas, and we're not afraid to spark arguments, and this is why we're cited widely in places like Slate, the Times Book section and its blogs (Arts Beat, Idea of the Day, now defunct, or Freakonomics), on Arts and Letters Daily, at The New Yorker's Book Bench blog or in The New Republic, in Best American Essays–to shamelessly name a few.
PAGES TO PIXELS
By pairing "Art and Politics," does Guernica encounter any difficulties? It seems that often, if art becomes the vessel of political ideals, something may be muddled.
GUERNICA MAGAZINE
To look at art and politics in the same space is not necessarily to make one the vessel of the other. If done with a clear mind, the effect is the opposite of muddling. But let's back up. I'd say the onus should be on skeptics: what is the problem with a total freedom that allows artists and writers to think about whatever they want?
That's what we tell other countries––when, say, China, imprisons its artists for their politics, right? Our first instinct isn't to say, You shouldn't talk about those things together. Our first instinct is to praise freedom, and condemn whoever abridges it to protect their narrow political interests. So is the freedom to write about politics, if you want, a freedom that good artists know not to use? Well, not when we're looking beyond the United States. Why is that?
Actually, it's one of the oldest of the received ideas from the middle of the 20th century; during the Cold War there was a systematic campaign by U.S. intelligence to fund literary magazines and arts movements (such as abstract expressionism) that divorced art from politics.
Peter Matthiessen is on record admitting that the magazine he founded, The Paris Review, was launched, unbeknown to its much more famous editor, George Plimpton, as a CIA front, or at least with CIA money. (I've been reading about this period of "literary renaissance" in Frances Stonor Saunders's Cultural Cold War.) I'm sure the effects of this are complicated to trace. But your question suggests this campaign (to beat the Russians for influence in Western Europe, using cultural assets) was wildly successful.
Is Orwell's precision muddled by his span of literary writing and politics? Is George Saunders's work muddled by its total cultural critique? Would Asia's first Nobel laureate, Rabindranath Tagore, have been better off if he specialized his knowledge in one field, and never thought broadly about the problems of nationalism, English occupation, poetry, and spirituality?
On the other hand, I should also quote The New Yorker's Peter Schjeldahl in his 2006 Guernica interview: "My problem with political art is not that it's bad art necessarily, but that it is terrible politics." So we look at them next to each other, but our poetry section isn't weighing in on the debt crisis. Koch-funded Tea Party stupidity can't really be captured in a sonnet.