P / Data

What It Costs to Publish 1 Short Story: Submission Fees, Counted

The better the magazine, the more likely it charges you to submit. 3 numbers, the arithmetic for 20 submissions, & 3 ways to spend less.

Share
What It Costs to Publish 1 Short Story: Submission Fees, Counted

Publishing a short story in a literary magazine is a numbers game before it is anything else. A finished story goes out again & again until an editor says yes, & a growing share of those tries now carry a fee. This post counts what that adds up to for 1 story, shows where the money goes, & gives you 3 ways to send fewer, better-aimed submissions.

The Prestige Toll

Benjamin Davis, a cofounder of the submissions database Chill Subs, published the counts in Lit Hub in May 2025. Across every magazine in the Chill Subs database, about 13% charge a fee to submit. Among the top 1,000 magazines on Brecht De Poortere’s ranking, 24% charge. Among the top 100, 56% do.

I call this climb the Prestige Toll: the higher a magazine ranks, the more likely it charges you to be read. A writer who aims only at the best-known magazines pays the toll on more than half of what they send.

The better the magazine, the more often it charges

13%of all magazines in the Chill Subs database charge a submission fee
24%of the top 1,000 magazines charge
56%of the top 100 magazines charge
Counts: Benjamin Davis, Lit Hub, May 7, 2025. “Prestige Toll” is Poetic.ly’s term. poetic.ly

20 submissions, 5 price tags

Davis also reports that an average piece takes about 20 submissions to find a home. Take a $3 fee, the example he uses, & the bill for 1 published story depends on where you aim. The arithmetic is 20 submissions × the share of magazines that charge × $3.

Where you sendShare that chargeFees for 20 submissions
Only magazines with no fee0%$0.00
Any magazine in the database13%$7.80
The top 1,00024%$14.40
The top 10056%$33.60
Only magazines that charge100%$60.00

What 1 published story costs in fees

No-fee magazines only$0
Any magazine$7.80
Top 1,000$14.40
Top 100$33.60
Fee magazines only$60
20 submissions × share of magazines that charge × a $3 fee. Averages; contest entry fees are higher & are not counted. poetic.ly

These are averages, & they assume a flat $3. A writer with 5 stories in circulation multiplies each line by 5.

Where a $3 fee goes

By Davis’s arithmetic, a $3 fee leaves a magazine about $1.86 after the submission platform & card processing take their share: 62 cents of each dollar. Of the $33.60 a writer spends to place 1 story among the top 100, about $20.83 reaches magazines & about $12.77 goes to the companies in between.

Where a $3 fee goes

$1.86 to the magazine$1.14 in between
$1.86 of $3.00 is 62%. Source for the $1.86: Benjamin Davis, Lit Hub, May 7, 2025. poetic.ly

The fee is real money to a small magazine, & it is also a filter on who gets read: it selects for writers who can afford to pay it 20 times. Poetic.ly sends 40% of its own earnings to independent literary organisations, so that support for magazines does not have to arrive through a toll on writers.

3 ways to pay less: aim before you send

1. Read what a magazine publishes before you pay it. Our journal profiles measure 391 short stories from 6 journals: how long they run, how much is dialogue, who tells them & how they end. If your story sits far from a journal’s middle on every measure, that is $3 you can keep.

2. Measure your own story first. Paste it into Fabulist™. It measures your pages in your browser, uploads nothing, & ranks the journals whose published stories are built most like yours.

3. Count your odds. Submission Odds shows the chance of at least 1 acceptance from any number of submissions, so you can decide how many fees a story is worth before the first one.

Insights for Writers & Readers

Writers: budget by tier. At the top 100, plan on about $34 in fees for each story you place, & treat every well-aimed submission you do not have to send as money back. Look for the fee-free reading windows many magazines keep.

Readers: the magazines you read are paid for in part by the writers they turn away. A subscription does the same work as dozens of submission fees, & it does not ask a writer to pay to be considered.

Try it now

  • List the next 5 magazines you plan to send to, & mark which charge.
  • Open the profile of any that we have measured & compare its median length with your story’s.
  • Run your story through Fabulist™ & send first to the journal at the top of your ranking.

Source for the fee counts, the 20-submission average & the $1.86 figure: Benjamin Davis, “The Rise of the Submission Industrial Complex,” Lit Hub, May 7, 2025. The cost tables are Poetic.ly’s arithmetic from those figures. Method & sources.

Verse / versa,

Christian Harder

Data Share

P / Letter

Get the letter.

The only literary magazine built on a massive library of best-in-class texts. Unrivaled insights, analysis & writers’ tools, by prize-winning writers & data scientists.

Read more