Who Decides the National Book Award? 76 Years of Judges, Counted
✦ Prizecraft | Vol. 1, No. 4 ✦ 667 judges’ seats since 1950. 0 writing degrees in the 1950s, 56% in the 2010s, and 45 seats from 1 program.

Every prize has a second cast: the people in the room. The National Book Award has seated 667 of them in Fiction and Poetry since 1950, and their vote is final. Part 3 of this series measured what the winning poems and stories sound like. This part counts who chose them, and where they trained.
Inside this post
- 🪑 667 seats: every Fiction & Poetry judge, 1950 to 2026
- 🎓 0 writing degrees in the 1950s, 56% in the 2010s
- 🌽 45 seats held by graduates of 1 program
- 👩 Women: 21% of seats in the 1950s, 54% in the 2010s
- 📋 The 10 judges of 2026 + who they chose
- ✍️ Insights for Writers & Readers + Try it now
Where the count comes from
A prize has two sides, the books and the people who choose them. For the second side we used the Index of Major Literary Prizes, a public dataset built by the scholars Claire Grossman, Juliana Spahr and Stephanie Young and published by the Post45 Data Collective. It lists every National Book Award judge from 1950 to 2020 with their degrees: 607 seats in Fiction and Poetry. We added the 60 seats from 2021 to 2026 from the National Book Foundation’s own pages.

The degree arrives
In the 1950s, none of the 104 judges held a Master of Fine Arts in writing. In the 2010s, 56 of 100 did, and among poetry judges it was 34 of 50. The winners changed more slowly: 0 of 20 winners in the 1950s had the degree, and 9 of 20 in the 2010s. Of the 129 judges’ seats held by someone with an MFA, 45 went to graduates of one program, the Iowa Writers’ Workshop. (I am an Iowa MFA and a former fellow there, which I mention every chance I get. This time the data gave me an excuse.) Women held 21% of the seats in the 1950s and 54% in the 2010s.
Keep reading · free with a Poetic.ly account
You’ve read the first third. The rest is for subscribers, & subscribing is free.
Still inside:
- 📖 What the degree does not prove
- 📖 The 10 judges of 2026
- 📖 Insights for Writers & Readers
- 📖 Try it now
- 📖 The series: how literary prizes are decided
A free account takes an email address & about 10 seconds. It also brings you The Letter, our weekly newsletter.